Analyzing Arguments MCQs — Logical Reasoning
4 practice MCQs
The correct answer is marked on every question, with its full explanation.
Logical ReasoningAnalyzing Arguments PPSC FPSC NTSID: NWC-033
Statement: The government should ban the sale of tobacco products. Argument I: Yes, tobacco causes serious diseases. Argument II: No, the government earns large revenue from tobacco taxes. Which argument is strong?
- AOnly Argument I is strong. ✓ Correct answer
- BOnly Argument II is strong.
- CBoth arguments are strong.
- DNeither argument is strong.
✓ Correct answer: Only Argument I is strong.
Full explanation
Only Argument I is strong. Tobacco causes serious diseases, so protecting public health is a strong reason for a ban. Why the others are wrong: Only Argument II is strong. — revenue from tobacco taxes does not outweigh the harm to public health, so it is a weak argument. Both arguments are strong. — Argument II is weak, so both cannot be strong. Neither argument is strong. — Argument I is strong, so it is wrong to say neither is strong.
Logical ReasoningAnalyzing Arguments PPSC FPSC NTSID: LR-007
Statement: All schools should teach computer science from primary classes. Argument I: Yes, computers are now part of daily life and early learning builds skills. Argument II: No, young children should only play and not study. Which argument is strong?
- AOnly Argument I is strong ✓ Correct answer
- BOnly Argument II is strong
- CBoth arguments are strong
- DNeither argument is strong
✓ Correct answer: Only Argument I is strong
Full explanation
Only Argument I is strong. Argument I gives a real, practical reason: computers are part of daily life, so early learning is useful. Why the others are wrong: Only Argument II is strong — Argument II is weak because it claims children should only play, which is not a serious reason against teaching a subject. Both arguments are strong — Argument II is weak, so both cannot be strong. Neither argument is strong — Argument I is strong, so this is wrong.
Logical ReasoningAnalyzing Arguments PPSC FPSC NTSID: LR-026
Statement: The government should provide free books to all school students. Argument I: Yes, it will help poor students continue their studies. Argument II: No, students should buy their own books. Which argument is strong?
- AOnly Argument I is strong ✓ Correct answer
- BBoth arguments are strong
- CNeither argument is strong
- DOnly Argument II is strong
✓ Correct answer: Only Argument I is strong
Full explanation
Only Argument I is strong. Argument I gives a real reason: free books would help poor students continue their studies. Argument II only says students should buy their own books, which does not answer the problem of poor students who cannot afford books. Why the others are wrong: Only Argument II is strong — Argument II is weak because it ignores the poor students the proposal is meant to help. Both arguments are strong — Argument II is weak, so both cannot be strong. Neither argument is strong — Argument I is strong, so this cannot be right.
Logical ReasoningAnalyzing Arguments PPSC FPSC NTSID: LR-045
Statement: The government should make the use of helmets compulsory for all motorcycle riders. Argument I: Yes, helmets save lives in road accidents. Argument II: No, helmets are uncomfortable to wear. Which argument is strong?
- AOnly Argument II is strong
- BBoth arguments are strong
- COnly Argument I is strong ✓ Correct answer
- DNeither argument is strong
✓ Correct answer: Only Argument I is strong
Full explanation
Argument I is strong because saving lives is a good reason to make helmets compulsory, while discomfort is a weak reason against it. The correct answer is Only Argument I is strong. Why the others are wrong: Only Argument II is strong — discomfort is not a good reason to reject a life-saving rule. Both arguments are strong — Argument II is weak, so both cannot be strong. Neither argument is strong — Argument I is strong, so this is wrong.
Practise these MCQs interactively →
← Logical Reasoning MCQs